- Joined
- Aug 24, 2005
- Posts
- 913
- Reaction score
- 33
Although it wasn't Alistair Darling who handed over the disk to the courier, it was a department under his control, can MP's only be found culpable if they are involved in an incident in the 1st person, if this is the case then they will never be responsible for anything that goes wrong in their departments.
Not knowing the full details of what happened, we can really say for sure who is to blame. However, my point is that if 1 person can do something wrong and as a result get the MP in charge of that department the sack, then all it takes is for a Conservative supporting civil servant to 'take a hit for the team' and do something wrong to cause Labour a headache!
What they should be judged on is whether it could have been prevented, and how they deal with the problem once it has been brought to their attention. In this case the rules where there but had been broken by the member of staff. Perhaps there should be extra safeguards in place to prevent the copies being made in the first place, but without knowing how the data is used it is impossible to have any fair and unbiased view on that.
Never could understand the logic of ministers being made heads of departments in areas in which they probably have little knowledge or experience. One week they're looking after transport the next the economy, wouldn't it make more sense to elect people with real world business experience in the relevant area to the position.
Agree with that totally, which is why they rely so much on the civil service staff in their departments to keep things running correctly.