These days, people are more concerned whether the domain/website is trustworthy. Like trustworthy enough to convince them to type-in their credit card and buy your merchandise.
A lot of "keyword-quality" domains nowadays, have been poisoned by low-quality content, parked by domainers, or even used for scams. And people these days who spend so much time on the internet, can now see the connection that when they type some keyword phrases on Google, and the domain that first shows up is like an "exact-match" domain, and what they get is poor content quality (if not scams), they tend to acquire a stigma against keyword domains.
But if it's a brandable domain, something that you can "remember" even while you're on a bus or eating in a restaurant, people tend to believe you are a serious merchandiser who is trying to protect a "brand". And if you are trying to protect a "brand", it comes with logic that you won't try to scam your customers, because you don't want your brand to be destroyed.