Enjoy unlimited access to all forum features for FREE! Optional upgrade available for extra perks.

No $17 million rebate for struggling new gTLDs - Colin Campbell Comments

dog

Joined
Feb 9, 2017
Posts
345
Reaction score
50
ICANN has turned down a request for about $17 million to be refunded to under-performing new gTLD registries.

The organization cannot spare the cash from its $96 million new gTLD program war chest because it does not yet know how much it will need to spend in future, Global Domains Division president Akram Atallah told registries this week.

Source - http://domainincite.com/22053-no-17-million-rebate-for-struggling-new-gtlds

Colin Campbell, the CEO and co-founder of .CLUB domains, commented below the article.

New domain registires should get no reduction in ICANN fees. Also why is it ICANN's job to market new domain extensions? They are supposed to an be independent governing organisation.

Fact 1: Many entrepreneurs and visionaries went into this market to support greater options for consumers (Yes with the intent of making money). We are beginning to see competition and innovation in the industry but lack of awareness has slowed progress.

Fact 2: ICANN has $350 million from auctions and application fees remaining that was generated by the new gTLD industry. To tax a fledgling industry trying to get off the ground, hoarding funds by ICANN and not returning it is in an injustice.

Fact 3: The RYSG proposal that .CLUB supported was, and I admit, self serving for the industry as the benefit would go to the registries and not the greater community.

I believe that it makes sense for the RYSG and ICANN to take another approach on this issue; one where the benefit would support ICANN, domain investors, consumers, the registrars and the registries.

There are two specific proposals at .CLUB that we have considered that would achieve a more equitable approach:

1. A broad awareness campaign for the new gTLDs to support global awareness and global acceptance in the amount of $4 million per year. This could be earmarked to support dozens of trade shows globally in every region of the world.

2. A temporary 3 year ICANN tax reduction to .18 cents from .25 cents (which equals what the registrars currently pay ICANN on every domain year). ($5 million total)

This drop in the bucket to ICANN, a $9 million proposal would have an impact by reducing prices for all users, increasing awareness, and ultimately increasing the demand for all domain names.

Colin Campbell, CEO .CLUB Domains
 
Last edited:
It's the same mentality of the bankers. It was intended to rip people off but didn't work so get someone else to pay for failure.
 
Last edited:
No domain bailouts, no bank bailouts! :)

It's the same mentality of the bankers. It was intended to rip people off but didn't work so get someone else to pay for failure.
 

The Rule #1

Do not insult any other member. Be polite and do business. Thank you!

Members online

☆ Premium Listings

Sedo - it.com Premiums

IT.com

Premium Members

Acorn Domains Merch
MariaBuy Marketplace

New Threads

Domain Forum Friends

Other domain-related communities we can recommend.

Our Mods' Businesses

Perfect
Laskos
*the exceptional businesses of our esteemed moderators
General chit-chat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    @Admin please enable the chat visible to unregistered users, or who haven't signed in their accounts. Tx
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    please
    brave_qptn86fptt-png.4616
  • D AcornBot:
    DLOE has left the room.
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    also, please keep the restriction in regards to posting > posting permission should be available to members only
  • Daniel - Monetize.info @ Daniel - Monetize.info:
    Welcome everyone!
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    @Daniel - Monetize.info
    chrome_8fedcfysiy-png.4617
    .. can you see this one?
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    nice, isn't it? :)
  • alan AcornBot:
    alan has left the room.
    • Wow
    Reactions: Jam
  • alan AcornBot:
    alan has joined the room.
  • alan AcornBot:
    alan has left the room.
  • alan AcornBot:
    alan has joined the room.
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    Hi Alan
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    long time no see
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    hows parachute doing?
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    :) huhhh.. Joe Rogan has just published an interview with Donald Trump
    To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
    For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    almost 3 hours..
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    morning all :)
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    .. is anyone going to domain day in Dubai or icann Turkey?
    • Like
    Reactions: gdomains
  • boxerdog AcornBot:
    boxerdog has left the room.
  • Helmuts @ Helmuts:
    Greetings from Istanbul, Turkey!
  • alan AcornBot:
    alan has left the room.
  • C AcornBot:
    cav has left the room.
      C AcornBot: cav has left the room.
      Top Bottom