To share my recent test on outreach:
60 .co.uk EMD / Keyword domains, mostly service / small business keywords - I searched Google of the “exact match” keyword string, and sent emails to anyone paying for exact match Google AdWords, and / or the top page of results.
Also thought I’d been ‘touched by genius’ when I came up with the idea of sending emails to the webmasters of those ranking / ad paying sites, thinking they would be happy to pitch my domains to their clients, cause it would lead to more work for them…
Method: emailed manually (ie: one at a time) from a branded Gmail account, personalised emails using an email address from a ‘marketing & design agency’ website.
Results:
550 emails sent
5 responses asking for info / prices
0 sales
I was pitching at mid £xxx prices - only got a single response with a firm offer of £100 from a webmaster, which I accepted, then they ghosted me
So for me it confirmed what others have shared before, and from personal experience from interacting with many small business owners - and that’s most of the small business community have no appreciation / don’t share our perspective on the value of domain names.
Also I’m mindful of email deliverability rates - cold emails rarely end up in the primary inbox, so I expect far less than 50% were actually read by someone who was a decision maker.
But based on that sample size, in my experience it isn’t worth the time required to research and send by cold email, for keyword domains.
In the future, for Premium / higher value / SEO domains / web sites, I reckon the only way would be to search the website / LinkedIn / call to find out a decision maker, then cold call / make an appointment to talk about ‘a unique domain name opportunity’ or ‘digital business development ideas’… etc - but again low chances of success…
Would love to hear about any strategy others have used, and found to be repeatable / commercial viable.